The testflights from yesterday clearly showed the need for parameter tuning. So we dedicated today purely to finding the best parameters.
The be short, we failed. After much testing and tuning we can say, that we did not find the best parameters and even have more problems than yesterday.
Yesterday we noted that our gier was periodically swinging. So we tried to fix this today and had to notice that as soon as the gier integral gets a bit bigger the periodic swinging starts. Even when we configured a differential part of 80. Only reducing the integral part to -3 ot -5 helped and even then we had a small periodic movement on our gier.
Furthermore we now have a aperiodic tremble on nick and roll. We tried to compensate with a bit of differential and less proportional, but we could not eliminate it fully.
It seems our parameter tuning turned out to be a bad idea. On the whole the UAVP flies less stable than yesterday and we do not know why.
The problems started with the upgrade to the version 3.12 of the software. It's clear that the changes in the software required changes in the parameter (compass support & differences in P & D calculations of the closed-loop control). But up to now we could not find really perfect parameters.
Here come some movies of our testing today.
First we show you the flip my brother got today. We do not really know what caused it:
Get the Flash Plugin to see this movie.
Next I show you some of my testflights. If you watch carefully, you see the tremble on nick and gier as well as the periodic movement on gier:
Get the Flash Plugin to see this movie.
The result of my last flight was another broken propeller...
We will ponder the results of today tests and the try to fix the parameter debacle.
Expect more to follow...
Hello Again,
Great posts! It would not be fun if it was not a challenge. I am sure you will figure out all the kinks (and post them so I don’t have to repeat them :) ). I am looking forward to reading about your progress.
Kevin
Welcome back Kevin,
Thanks again for the flowers! You're right, it would not be fun if it was not a challange, but on days like yesterday I curse it.
Wonderful weather to fly outside and we were sitting inside figuring out why the heck the thingy would not fly. Then finally realizing that setting one parameter (gier-I) to zero resolves the problem and would have already resolved it a day ago as well!
*sight*
Now, anyway... it flys! Yes, it flys again and I will show you a movie proving it soon!
Regards
- Amir